The New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) is a tribunal that hears and determines a wide range of disputes across New South Wales, Australia. These disputes can range from tenancy disputes to consumer complaints and building disputes. The tribunal is tasked with ensuring that disputes are resolved in a fair and just manner, with a focus on finding solutions that meet the needs of all parties involved.

Recently, Seán McNally (quantum expert) was called upon to provide evidence in a building dispute case that was being heard by the NCAT. The dispute involved a homeowner and a builder who had been contracted to replace the roof on the homeowner’s property. The homeowner claimed that the builder had breached the terms of the contract by failing to complete the work to a satisfactory standard, and that the work had resulted in significant damage to the property.

The builder, on the other hand, argued that the homeowner had been difficult to work with and had repeatedly changed the scope of the project, which had resulted in delays and additional costs. The builder claimed that any damage to the property was a result of the homeowner’s own actions, rather than the builder’s negligence.

As part of the proceedings, the NCAT called upon Seán to provide evidence on the financial impact of the alleged breaches of contract and the resulting damage to the property. Seán provided a detailed analysis of the costs associated with the project, including the cost of materials, labour, and equipment. Seán was also able to provide an estimate of the costs associated with repairing the damage to the property.

Seán was able to present his evidence in a clear and concise manner, making use of diagrams, charts, and other visual aids to help the tribunal understand the complex financial information. Seán was also able to answer questions from the tribunal and the parties involved, demonstrating his expertise in the field of quantum analysis and their ability to communicate complex financial information in a way that was easily understood.

As a result Seán’s evidence, the NCAT was able to make an informed decision about the dispute. The tribunal found that the builder had breached the terms of the contract and had been negligent in their work, resulting in damage to the homeowner’s property. The builder was ordered to pay damages to the homeowner, which were based on the estimates provided by Seán.

The successful result achieved in this case highlights the importance of expert evidence in resolving complex disputes. By calling upon experts in their respective fields, tribunals like the NCAT are able to ensure that disputes are resolved fairly and justly.

In conclusion, the successful outcome of the building dispute case heard by the NCAT demonstrates the importance of expert evidence in resolving complex disputes. By providing specialised knowledge and analysis, experts like Seán in this case can help tribunals to make informed decisions based on objective data and evidence. The successful result achieved in this case serves as a reminder of the importance of impartial and objective evidence in the resolution of disputes, and the vital role that experts play in achieving these outcomes.

Contact us today to see what our Experts can do for you.